A Roaring Twenties Estate in Green Township

If the walls could talk in this luxurious dwelling, they’d tell of flappers, speakeasies, and wild characters in Cincinnati’s history.

Driving along Cleves Warsaw Pike, an iron gate, stone wall, and quaint gate lodge are all that’s visible of the nearly nine-acre estate known as Covedale Gables. Set far back from the road, down a long, winding lane, the historic Tudor Revival harbors tales of bootleggers, speakeasies, and Prohibition profits. Its walls cleverly conceal hidden passages. It’s Peaky Blinders, Queen City style.

5114 Cleves Warsaw Pike’s original owner, William Lucking, was a prominent businessman, real estate developer, and distiller whose deep pockets allowed him to commission a home of unparalleled luxury. Built in 1921, it fully embodies the glamour and prosperity of the Roaring Twenties. Lucking hired a premiere firm from New York—R.C. Hunter & Brothers—to design the 4,800-square-foot home.

“While many homes offer updated finishes, very few offer this level of architectural pedigree, original craftsmanship, and a connection to Cincinnati’s history,” says listing agent Grayson Combs. No expense appeared to be too great, because the quality of materials used throughout is nothing short of jaw-dropping. Though the exterior resembles a picturesque, storybook cottage, it’s a prime example for not judging a book by its cover.

This effect is felt immediately upon entering the home, as the foyer is wrapped in floor-to-ceiling marble that’s complemented by limestone cladding. The grand, swirling staircase is its own work of art, with ornate bronze filigree forming the delicate baluster. Off the foyer, grandeur extends in all directions. The oversized rooms were made for entertaining, and no doubt a show of prestige.

Lucking was involved with George Remus, who was known as the ‘king of the bootleggers’ during Prohibition. He provided financial backing to Remus, and later served time for doing so. Remus had quite a reputation, and his $50,000 bond (for charges related to violating the Federal Prohibition Act) was said to be, at that time in 1921, the largest ever required in a federal case in Cincinnati. Remus was also the inspiration behind F. Scott Fitzgerald’s Jay Gatsby of The Great Gatsby.

“This colorful history adds intrigue to the home—especially with the presence of the hidden speakeasy in the lower level,” says Combs. Entry to the speakeasy is concealed via a false marble wall located just off the front door. Going down the steps feels like passing through a time portal, and you can almost hear the jiving jazz notes of “The Charleston” playing in the spacious room. There’s a built-in bar and fireplace. Unique symbols pepper the walls, fireplace tile, and ceiling, leading one to ponder the deeper significance of their unknown meaning.

Back upstairs, past the staircase, a large solarium shines with natural light streaming through arched windows and French doors. The dazzling effect is enhanced by an arched ceiling covered in silverleaf. At the time the house was built, it was a popular design choice to create a jewel box sensation within a room. Walls are not ordinary plaster here, but rather lattice-covered travertine stone. While the room is certainly a feast for the eyes, auditory senses are soothed by a built-in fountain, its motif one of cherubs and flowers. French doors lead out to a heart-shaped terrace, appropriately painted red.

Not to be outdone by the gilded solarium, the expansive living room features the same attention to detail and intricate craftsmanship, but with a more masculine aesthetic. Walls are covered in exquisitely carved wood paneling, while the ceiling adds great interest through the texture of its ornate (and impressive) plasterwork. Leaded glass windows, complete with stained glass in a crest design, form a bank on one side of the room. A fireplace alcove boasts an impressive scale and fine detailing that make it feel as if it were plucked from a castle.

Covedale Gables has only changed hands a few times in its hundred-year history. Incredibly, many features have been preserved, a testament to the care of its current owners. Delightful details, like original tile in vibrant colors, remain intact in the three-and-a-half bathrooms. All three bedrooms are generously sized, while the primary shines with intricate trim and molding, window seat, and hallway of glass-front wardrobes. There are charming sitting areas and conversation nooks sprinkled throughout the home, offering a chance to slow down and enjoy the surrounding grandeur.

Nature lovers will be enchanted by the vast amount of green space. “The nearly nine acres of pastures and woodlands create an unmatched sense of peace and seclusion,” says Combs, “yet you’re just minutes from the conveniences of Cincinnati’s West side.” Those with green thumbs can appreciate unique features like sunken gardens and statuary.

The property is brimming with old world touches that cannot be found elsewhere. These features, paired with the overall historical significance, put 5114 Cleves Warsaw Pike in a league of its own. Combs echoes this sentiment, “It’s a once-in-a-generation opportunity to own an estate like this.”